Thursday, February 12, 2015

You may be wrong, for all I know but you may be write.

Ok you guys... We're going for a record this time. 3 comments! Can I get a 3?.... and then and then you guys say THREE!! 

    Very good. Well then! Let's talk a bit about writing. For any of you cats that had the chance to hear my "4 Truths and a Lie", you will have heard that I watch a bit of Doctor who when I can.

Yeah, Yeah... I hear ya. I'll save you the trouble. "I am thirty-four years old, I am thrice divorced, and I live in a box down by the river.

         A fine show and all.. but not really the point. I was able to take HIST 4810 for the second time last semester (the first time was failed due to a lack of trying hard enough on my part and the teacher trying too hard), and I was super blessed to be able to take it from a professor who just liked to read. He told us that if we'd like to we could, instead of writing the normal research paper, we could write a piece of historical fiction. I jumped at the chance. Doctor Who, lends itself as the perfect back drop for a historical fiction piece. For those of you who want to read it, I'm copying and pasting it in here. For those of you who don't want to read it, I will make it clear when to stop scrolling.
Doctor Who and the Timelock[1]
By: Keith Jackman
History 4810
            The Ice World and his betrayal of the Ice Warriors became a mere memory to the Time Lord as his TARDIS traveled to its destination.  A destination that was quite unknown to its pilot, The Time Meddler. A man of simple needs and desires, all he had wanted was to change history, but it’s a bit difficult when he couldn’t decide on a destination.
            “Curse you Doctor! Had you taken any part besides my directional unit, I could have been able to replace it with spares on board. You wily little sneak!”
            Still wearing his monk habit from his previous outing, (he had decided it was actually quite comfortable) he sat down with his cup of tea.  Suddenly, the center console of his TARDIS stopped and there was a clunk as he landed, which spilled his tea slightly. Putting down his cup, he approached the controls, scanned the atmosphere and looked at the monitor to see where he had landed.
            On the screen he saw a bustling city, with trees, bicycles and pagodas.  There was no sign of Ice Warriors, The Doctor or anything else unpleasant in sight. He quickly put his sandals back on and opened the doors to explore the new place.
            Upon exiting, he noticed that there was a group of Japanese soldiers marching towards him, quickly he got out of their way and hid behind the TARDIS to avoid questioning. Seeing a map on the wall he realized he was near the beach. Given the troops, he decided it would be better if he got away from this part of the city and decided to head for the coast. Perhaps he could take a relaxing walk around the beach for now and see what type of mischief he could cause in this time period later.
            Suddenly as he approached the sand, he heard a sound which was familiar to him. (WAAHHHHOoooo WAAAhhhhhOOOO WaaaHHHOooo Ka-Chunk!) He dove into the bushes at his right as a 1960s style, blue, English style Police Box appeared no less than 20 feet away from him. As he watched, a man with a mop-top hairstyle and baggy clothes came out of it, as well as a young man wearing a kilt. He listened in on their conversation.
            “Well it does seem rather odd that the Time Lords would make you come here without telling you, what in the world you were supposed to do,” the Scottish one said.
            “Jaime! I was just grateful that they told us where we were going. That’s certainly a relief isn’t it?” The Doctor replied.
            “Well I suppose so. But to say “You’re going to Earth, August 6, 1945 to stop a disturbance that may happen”, is a fairly vague way to go about giving reassurance.”
            “The date is familiar to me; let’s have no worries about that now. Let’s just keep our eyes open and we’ll figure it out as we go. Come on now.” He pulled out a recorder and started playing “Merrily we Roll Along” as they walked down the beach.
            “At last” cried The Time Meddler, “my moment has arrived to pay a visit to my old friend’s TARDIS and take back what is rightfully mine!”
            He ran from the bushes and into the Doctor’s TARDIS. Upon entering he saw almost immediately that he wouldn’t be able to disable the TARDIS by stealing its directional unit. Unfortunately, the Doctor’s model was an outdated model and would never converge with his newer Mark IV.  But upon further inspection he found that there was an option that may be just as tasty. Sitting on the center console was a Stattenheim remote control, a device used to call the TARDIS to the user no matter what the location or time. He swiftly snatched it up, tuned it to his own TARDIS, pressed the button and escaped back to the beach. His ship appeared just in front of him, also in the shape of a Police Box. As he started to make his way back into his own ship, he heard footsteps running towards him.
            “What do you mean we need to leave?! We just got here Doctor!” It was Jamie and the Doctor.
            “I just realized why today’s date had any significance! It is 8:12 am. If we are here at 8:15 we will be one of hundreds of thousands of victims, killed by one of the most deadly weapons known to mankind!” [2]
            They stopped running momentarily as they saw that there were two TARDIS in front of them with the Time Meddler staring in the middle.
            “Hello Mortimus.”
            “Goodbye Doctor” he said and with that returned to The Doctor’s TARDIS, locked the door and started the take off procedures.
            “Doctor! He’s getting away with our TARDIS.”
            “We don’t have time to worry about that Jamie! Look!”
            Overhead and in the distance a few miles out, they saw an enormous B-29 Superfortress bomber. From the way it was flying it could be guessed that the payload was just about to fall. Without another word to each other they scrambled into the Monk’s TARDIS and raised the shields. They had no sooner done so than they were rocked to one side. The shields protected them from the blast, but the blinding light from the blast still filled the room.  Suddenly there was a flicker of light and movement from the motor within the center console. It started to move up and down and immediately they took off! Realizing it could get out of hand quick, the Doctor felt his way to the controls and closed the door, just as another jolt knocked them both off their feet.
            “Doctor! Where are we going?!” Jamie yelled as he struggled to get back up on his feet.
            “I have no idea Jamie! I haven’t touched the controls and….!” He went to his coat pockets and found that the remote control was not there. “Oh dear….. Jaime, I fear that we may be in for a bumpy ride.”
            “You don’t mean…”
            “Yes, that Meddling Monk has my remote control!”
            “Yes I do Doctor.” The image of the Monk appeared on the monitor. “And you’re going to help me accomplish a few things before I give it back. I don’t ask for much, I just want you to alter a few unpleasant events that occurred.”
            The Doctor, having recently regained his footing, sat down hard in a nearby seat. “You seem to have my back up against the wall and a leash around my neck.”
            The Monk smiled grimly, “I believe you’re right old friend, but I’ll make it easy for you. All I want you to do is simply show up.” And with that the screen went black.
            “Boy, today hasn’t been our day for receiving clear instructions at all has it?” Jamie stated exasperatedly.  “Well, what are you waiting for? Grab the controls; let’s go tell the Time Lords we never found their ‘disturbance’.” 
            “Don’t you understand Jamie, there’s no way to control this TARDIS while it is being called by the remote.” He wiggled a few handles and knobs to no effect. “Our only shot is to see where he takes us and try to hi-jack our TARDIS back from him.”
            The monitor started to flicker into life as they landed. They read a sign in the window of the building they were facing that read “Buckman’s Tavern”. In the distance, on the roadway, they saw two opposing forces standing against each other. No one was fighting, but the energy between each of them was visible. [3]
            “Where are we Doctor?”
            “As best as I can tell from the clothing and firearms, I would say that we are very near the end of the 18th century. I would further venture a guess that the forces are the American settlers and British Army.”[4]
            “Well now we’ve landed, let’s get out of here!” Jamie went to the controls and pushed a large yellow button. The TARDIS rumbled a bit and a loud “BANG!” occurred. Outside, the light on top of the TARDIS shot off and a red and white striped parachute emerged, covering the view on the monitor. The Doctor, shaking his head, pulled a lever next to the button that sucked the parachute sucked back in.
            “Please don’t touch things Jamie; you have no idea where he’s been.”
            On the screen, they were startled to see that the forces had started firing at each other. Bullets were coming in volleys upon volleys. People were scurrying around trying to find safety. And as they watched, they saw men falling on either side clutching their wounds.
            “You fools!” The Monk appeared on the screen again. “Is it really so hard to just be visible. You were supposed to land right between them! The faulty directional unit must be altering your trajectory.” With that he disappeared again, and the TARDIS once again jolted from its position and disappeared with a wisp from behind the tavern.
            The Doctor pulled himself up and turned to Jaime “I do wish he would stick around long enough to ask him about what he is expecting from us.”
            They landed again with a jolt. “That didn’t take long at all Doctor!”
            “No it didn’t Jaime; I expect our omnipotent friend is having some troubles controlling my older model while controlling his by remote. Our TARDIS together are now locked together. They are fused by their destination targeting systems. They’re equal now, aside from mechanics. My suspicion is that we simply switched places, though the blast from the atomic bomb seems to have recharged the communication circuits. I have never spoken across the years like this. However with the lack of Directional Control unit from this TARDIS, it is taking us to locations that it feels have a familiar tone or something connecting the previous place it has been sent.”
            The TARDIS had transformed into a doorway on the side of large building with a balcony out front. The Doctor and Jamie exited and walked around to the front of the building. There was some type of excitement going on in front. As Jaime turned the corner and saw the British soldiers he couldn’t help but stop in his tracks. He noticed that there were quite a few others that were throwing objects and yelling at the infantry men. [5]
            He scooped up a handful of snow himself “You stupid Redcoats! Go home already would ya!” The Doctor tried to stop him but it was too late; the Highlander had thrown a wallop of a throw and had knocked the man down. They could hear him shout, “Fire, damn you!” and his gun went off into the crowd. For a moment things all stood still.[6]
            The Doctor then turned to Jaime and whispered in his ear, “When I say run, run. ...RUN!”  Then the British started to fire in earnest at the crowd. The Doctor and Jaime bolted back into the TARDIS and the Doctor closed the door. “You stupid, stupid boy!” He yelled at Jaime. “What were you thinking?!”
            “I’m sorry Doctor. But I’ve spent so much time reacting that way to the Red Coats that it just came natural. Besides, it looked like they couldn’t even put a proper volley together.”
            “Really, Jaime? Let’s take a look, shall we?” The Doctor turned on the monitor to see at least 3 bodies lying in the street.[7] But before they could reflect on the scene the TARDIS dematerialized again and they were off.
            The TARDIS fell to one side and spit them out in the middle of a parking lot, and then landed next to them, disguised as a car. There were many people there, but they didn’t seem to be paying much attention to the two of them nor to the fact that a Volkswagon appeared out of nowhere. Instead, they were chanting and protesting by throwing rocks. About a hundred meters in front of the Doctor and Jamie was their target.[8] Troops with guns at the ready, turned as a group of students rushed them from the east and shots were fired. All around the duo people scattered. One young girl, not twenty yards from them was hit on her left side.[9] She twirled and hit the ground, her Kent State University sweater splattered with blood. Up ahead of them a young man’s head jerked back and he fell flat on his face. [10]
            Jamie could take no more of it and reached to try to open the TARDIS, but the crowd swept him up as they fled.
            “Jamie!” The Doctor reached out for him and grabbed his wrist as he held on to the door handle of the Beatle. He was able to open the door just in time. He threw Jamie in the TARDIS as there was a break in the crowd. Jaime pulled the Doctor in quickly behind him.
            “Having fun Doctor?” The Monk spoke softly from his perch on the monitor. “Evidently I ended up “before” you this time, but the gap is getting smaller. I do hope you have changed things where you are. I couldn’t do a thing here”
            “You maniac… you fiend! We won’t be your puppets you hear me?!” The Doctor yelled at him, but again, he was gone.
            Jaime was evidently getting more and more shaken up by sites that he was seeing.  The Doctor seeing this comforted him, “Don’t worry Jamie, I have a plan. I just need to stop so I can work the controls.”
            “I hope so Doctor. So much of the things we have seen have been so careless and crass. Like there was no purpose at all behind much of it.”
            The Doctor nodded as they again landed with a thud. As they stepped out of the TARDIS they saw they had landed in the middle of what they could only suppose was Hell itself. The huts surrounding them were all on fire. There were piles of burning personal belongings and dead  half-naked bodies everywhere they looked. They saw a helicopter fly off full of people who looked like they had lived here.[11] Two soldiers came running around the corner and pointed their rifles at them.  One lowered his rifle though and said to his companion, “These are definitely not Charlie. Let’s get going.” The other said “Medina said to ‘kill anything walking crawling or growing in My Lai’”[12] and cocked his firearm. His companion swiped at his barrel and put it down in the ground. “That’s enough shooting for one day.” Then to the Doctor and Jaime, “You two get the hell out of here.”
            The Doctor quickly grabbed something by his foot, a bullet shell, and turned with Jaime to rush back into the TARDIS.  The Doctor immediately started tinkering with the controls. Jamie covered his eyes and sat on the steps. “Don’t worry Jaime; it will all be all over soon. All I have to do is reverse the polarity of the neutron flow…. Add the conductor.” Sparks flew and the lights dimmed aside from an electrical beam that was flowing right in front of him. “I need something else!” He reached in his pockets. “Ah! A jelly baby! How perfect!” He threw it in the beam, closed the door and then put his arm around Jaime.
“Hold on tight! Transmat Beaming can leave you a bit squeamish.” He said as he flipped a switch on the nearby wall and walked them on to a platform in the corner. In almost an instant they had switched places with the Monk and were back in their own TARDIS.
            “Ha!” The Doctor said, “Now not only will you not know where you’re going, but the sugar content from that jelly baby will make it so you get there…. Let’s just say much later than you expected.”
            “Blast you Doctor!” The Monk cried as he was slowly sucked to his next destination. “You could have saved thousands of lives! But instead you had to stick with the insipid Time Lords and their non-intervening! Their blood is on your hands Doctor! You hear me!  You, who claim to be a pacifist and yet mediated NOTHING when given the chance. You are just as guilty as the ones who pulled the triggers!” He continued to rant, but by then the Doctor’s TARDIS had drifted far away from reception of his signals.
            “But why did you do it Doctor?” Jamie wept, “All of those people died. The Monk’s intentions were good; we could have saved thousands of lives and you refused!”
            The Doctor slowly sat down next to Jaime and took a deep breath, thinking carefully about what he would say next before he said it. After a few moments slowly he spoke.
            “It isn’t our place to meddle in history. The Monk’s motivations were not to save lives, but to see for his own selfish purposes if he might change the fixed points time is destined to go through. Pride was his motivation, not love. Even if we did wish to make it our mission to travel back in time and try to fix all the massacres and genocides, you can't rewrite history. Not one line.[13] Even if you were to try, time has a way of correcting itself. What is in the past is what has made us who we are today. We are the inescapable result of our tragedies.”[14] He stood slowly, and helped his companion up, and looked him square in the eyes. “But it is essential Jamie to remember all lives are important — including ours — and as we see, so we learn... Our destiny is in the stars, so let's go and search for it. Here… have a jelly baby.”[15] With that he went to the controls and piloted the ship away from the hostilities of man.




[1] Doctor Who is copyright © by the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC). No copyright infringement is intended.
[2] Millett, Allan Reed, and Peter Maslowski. "The United States and World War II: The Road to Victory." In For the Common Defense: A Military History of the United States from 1607 to 2012, 439. 3rd Ed., Free Press Trade Pbk. ed. New York: Free Press, 2012.
[3] Fischer, David Hackett. "The First Shot." In Paul Revere's Ride, 194-195. New York: Oxford University Press, 1994.

[4] Ibid.
[5] "Eyewitness Accounts of the Boston Massacre (1770)." American Revolution. Accessed December 8, 2014. http://alphahistory.com/americanrevolution/eyewitness-accounts-boston-massacre-1770/.
[6] Ibid.
[7] Ibid.
[8] Kent State: The Day the War Came Home. United States: Landmark Media, 2001. Film.
[9] Ibid.
[10] Ibid.
[11] Millett, Allan Reed, and Peter Maslowski. "The United States and World War II: The Road to Victory." In For the Common Defense: A Military History of the United States from 1607 to 2012, 559-560. 3rd Ed., Free Press Trade Pbk. ed. New York: Free Press, 2012.
[12] "Calley's Trial Puts Emphasis On CO." Bangor Daily News, December 21, 1970. Accessed December 7, 2014.
[13] Doctor Who: The Aztecs. Performed by William Hartnell. UK: BBC, 1963. Film.

[14] The Time Machine. United States: DreamWorks, 2002. DVD.

[15] Doctor Who: The Reign of Terror. Performed by William Hartnell. UK: BBC, 1964. Film.
 
You get this right?Phhhtt!
    I was so happy with the job that I did on it that I didn't care what kind of score I got on it. I was up late, so it was hard to find people to edit it, but I was lucky enough to find a fellow "Whovian" or two to look into it for me. I had a few things I cleaned up on it and then I sent it in to the professor. When he posted our scores he asked us to e-mail him if we would like any feedback. So I did! This is what he had to say back:

Hi Keith,

I loved your paper. I was a little stunned to see Dr. Who appear but your paper was the most creative piece of fiction submitted. I gave you max points because you tied in the fiction with accurate, well-researched history, and because you obviously worked hard to write this paper well. Your writing is crisp and clean and I enjoyed reading it very much. Great Job!

Best,

Jeff Bateman

Needless to say I was thrilled to death to see some appreciation for something I cared so much about and had worked so hard on. I think the reason that I was able to write it as well as I could was because I was able to choose what I wanted to write about. I hate it when I get backed in a corner to analyze some document and try to interpret it's meaning (right.... well not all the time. It's just when you have to write 8-10 pages about 3 paragraphs it can be a bit difficult.) I love to tell a good story and that was just what I was able to do in this situation. I never have thought it was a sin to let the students go hog wild when they write. His only guidelines were that it had to be 8-10 pages and that it had to have 3-5 different sources. (I could be wrong about the number of sources.) That freedom really let me blossom.

       Obviously, it could have gone through more editing and more revisions. I don't know... maybe it's the fact that he (the professor) had spent all of his life in the Air Force, that he didn't knit pick over the grammar and spelling of my work.  In all actuality, having finally gotten this submitted the morning of the final exam, and working on it all night, I think it turned out pretty good. I only had peer review, but I guess I would have felt like I was ruining the story by letting the professor look it over first. Because that was the case, I made extra sure that my sources were accurate and well chosen. That seemed to work just fine for him! So, I feel like I can assuredly put Level Three writing on this paper.

          I feel bad that I want to say this, but it's my blog so I'll say what I like.
Master of what? Doesn't even get a jelly baby. (But I get a jelly baby)

        The articles I read were all about rubrics and peer reviews and editing. Obviously, we don't want our students to turn in a bunch of rubbish (tee hee... rubbish!). But at the same time, you can edit the darn thing to death. Why not instead, let them learn how to write in their English class? I say, let them write from the heart in my class. If there is a great need to clean it up then we'll help them with that, but history is a fascinating enough subject, that you could take any time period and find someway that you could write from any interest, I feel. Maybe I'll end up getting into the saddle and will feel differently, but in the meantime, I feel like study will be more thorough, writing will be more passionate, and the students will be more appreciative of the subject if I just get out of the way and keep the guidelines to a minimum. My Mission President said the same thing to us about music, "You're smart enough to know what is going to uplift you. If it starts to become a problem for you, then we'll get stricter." I'm grateful my professor trusted me, and I will gladly pay that forward.

4 comments:

  1. Keith, again, I loved your enthusiasm in your post. I liked how found fun in writing a paper for history, and did so well. The one thing that I thought stood out the most was freedom let you blossom. I liked that phrase you use a lot. I think that would make for good writing from students, and I hate the idea of following something so closely with no room for creativity. I will take to heart that I will let students blossom by giving them freedom in writing.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Your posting brought out another great point...that it's important to allow choice in writing assignments, where possible. And it's also important to vary the genre for the assignments. There are some students who might thrive and enjoy writing a research paper...for instance, Paul, in his blog posting, talked about a research paper he was proud of. But you enjoyed the historical fiction instead of the research paper, which still let you apply your knowledge of history. So if you are going to require your students to all write in response to the same writing prompt, then you should vary what you have them write so that students can write research papers sometimes, they can write historical fiction sometimes, they can write mock facebook pages sometimes, and more.

    Thanks for a great posting!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Here...you reached your goal of getting three comments! But just because you cited Billy Joel in your title. :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Kieth,

    Now you have, not only three comments, but you have comments from three people.

    I really enjoyed reading your post. It was not only funny and creative, but it was also informative and well written. I agree that students should have freedom of choice, when applicable, in their writing assignments.

    Even though I believe writing should play a major role in the classroom, I do not believe that it should all be formal or even graded for that matter. Writing is a form of expression, and we should allow are students to express themselves.

    I love the idea of allowing students to write historical fiction because I plan some of my history lessons around historical fiction. There are times when you will have to have your students write more formal papers, but they should be graded more on there understanding of the concepts than they should be on their formal writing abilility

    ReplyDelete